Nutrition - how to rein in your complex carb intake for times when work drops

Starch or FibreBalancing different carbohydrate sources against changing requirements of fitness, injury and recoveryCarbohydrates are by far the largest component of any horse’s diet, typically two thirds by weight, yet we often focus more on other nutrients, such as protein—which in comparison forms only a small portion of the total diet at around 8-13%. Carbohydrates, specifically the balance between differing carbohydrate sources, influences three key areas relating to performance.The choice of carbohydrate influences the type of energy available, providing varying proportions of ‘fast release’ or ‘slow release’ energy. The type of carbohydrate chosen also impacts behaviour, increasing or decreasing risk of excitability and certain stereotypical behaviours. Last, but by no means least, the choice of carbohydrate and the way in which it is fed impacts digestive health and the ability of the digestive system to convert food to ‘fuel’ for the body.Getting the balance right between the different types of carbohydrates is important for getting the right results when having to adjust the intensity of training, when resting a horse and when working back up through the stages of fitness.What are carbohydrates?There are different ways of classifying or grouping carbohydrates, depending on whether you take things from the plant’s point of view or that of the digestive anatomy of the horse. Working with the horse in mind, carbohydrates are best classified by the section of the digestive system that they are processed in—either the small intestine or large intestine. The site of digestion determines the type of energy provided, often referred to as fast releasing for the small intestine and ‘slow releasing’ for the large intestine. The group of carbohydrates, known as hydrolysable carbohydrates, are the group behind the description of fast releasing, whilst the group known as fermentable carbohydrates are those forming the ‘slow releasing’ category. Within the fermentable group, there are three sub groups of rapid, medium and slow.   What are carbohydrates made of?There are many types of carbohydrates in the horse’s diet, ranging from simple sugars to more complex structures. They are defined by their degree of polymerisation, which refers to the way in which sugar units are joined together. How a carbohydrate is formed and the type of link present are important as they determine if digestion is possible in the small intestine or whether fermentation in the large intestine is required. This influences the type of energy available.For horses in training, the type of carbohydrate of particular interest is the polysaccharide group which includes starch, cellulose, hemicellulose and fructans amongst others. Starch is found in significant quantities in hard feeds, whilst cellulose and hemicellulose, amongst other fermentable carbohydrates are abundant in forages. Pasture is a source of fructans, which can change rapidly depending on growing conditions and daylight hours.StructureSingle sugars, also called simple sugars, comprise one unit only. They are categorised as monosaccharides—the most commonly known being glucose. For horses in training this is a highly valuable sugar as it is the main ‘fuel’ for muscles. Glucose forms the basis of many of the more complex structures of interest to horses in training.When two sugars join together, they are known as a disaccharide—the best known being lactose which is found in mare’s milk. Oligosaccharides refer to more complex structures where more units are joined together—a common example being fructo-oligosaccharide (FOS) which many horses in training are specifically fed as a prebiotic to support digestive function.Type of CarbohydrateExampleMonosaccharideGlucose, FructoseDisaccharideLactose, Sucrose, MaltoseOligosaccharideFructo-Oligosaccharide (FOS)PolysaccharideStarch, Cellulose, FructansPolysaccharides, our group of particular interest, are significantly more complex chains that are branched and are not so easily digested as the simple sugars. The branched nature of polysaccharides, such as starch and cellulose, are the result of links between chains of sugars. The type of link present determines whether or not it will be possible for the horse to digest this form of carbohydrate in the small intestine or not.Giles – ideally image of flat racing next to starch sectionStarchStarch is the primary carbohydrate of interest in our hard feeds. It is a hydrolysable carbohydrate, which can be digested in the small intestine, releasing glucose into the bloodstream. For horses in training this is the most important fast release energy source. Starch is found in all plants, with the highest quantities seen in cereals such as oats, barley and maize.Composition of cereals commonly used in racing feedsOatsBarleyMaizeWheatProtein%911811Fibre%11.34.822Oil%6.82.642.3Starch%3851.56360Starch is made up of two types of sugar chains: amylose and amylopectin, which are formed from glucose units. Amylose itself is easily digested, however amylopectin has a different type of bond connecting each branch, which the enzymes of the small intestine cannot break down. Feed processing, which changes the structure of starch and breaks apart the previously indigestible bonds, is therefore a key factor in ensuring that when starch is fed that the maximum amount of glucose is derived.Amylose and Amylopectin Feed processing comes in many forms, from simply crushing or rolling the grain to cooking techniques including micronizing, steam flaking, pelleting or extruding. The amount of processing required for what is deemed efficient digestion differs by grain type. Oats have a natural advantage within the cereal group as they can be fed whole, although processing can still improve digestion. Barley, wheat and maize cannot be fed whole or simply rolled. They require cooking to ensure that starch becomes available, and the impact of cooking processes is much greater for these grains.The availability of starch is assessed through the amount of glucose released into the blood after feeding. The study below shows the effect of steam cooking maize (corn) compared to two processes that simply change the physical appearance, cracking or grinding. Steam-flaked maize is more available as shown by the greater glucose response.Starch is a fast release energy source, being digested in the small intestine, and the term can easily be misunderstood. It does not mean that the horse will suddenly run at top speed nor appear to be fuelled by ‘rocket fuel’. The word ‘fast’ relates to the relatively short time it takes for digestion to occur and glucose to be available. Looking at the maize example, it is possible to see that glucose is found in the blood just 30 minutes after feeding. This is a rapid response compared to carbohydrates that are digested further down the digestive tract in the large intestine.Energy is energy, whichever source it comes from or how long it takes to digest. However, the type of energy, whether fast release or slow release, does impact behaviour, in particular affecting reactivity. When fed on higher-starch diets, horses are well documented to become more reactive, anxious and over excitable. Aside from the need for glucose as a fuel for performance and equally for recovery, its presence in the diet can increase reactivity. In a sport where speed and the ability to react quickly are an advantage, starch and its associated effects can be a positive. Like all nutrients, there is a fine balance to be had, and an excess of starch and over excitable behaviour are not desirable at certain stages of fitness. Starch excess should be avoided at all costs for horses prone to tying-up where excitable behaviour is a known risk factor.Giles – ideally image of national hunt racing next to fermentable carbohydrate sectionFermentable carbohydratesCellulose, as an example of the fermentable carbohydrate group, is similar to starch being composed of glucose units, however the type of bond is significantly different and can only be digested in the large intestine through bacterial fermentation. Cellulose is a key component of the cell wall of plants, including both cereals and forages but is found in the highest amounts within forages and some of the more fibrous co-products used in feeds, such as sugar beet pulp.The digestive process of bacterial fermentation that occurs in the large intestine yields different energy sources in comparison to the small intestine where glucose is the main product of starch digestion. Fermentation of cellulose and other fermentable carbohydrates, such as hemicellulose and lignocellulose, produce volatile fatty acids (VFAs). Like glucose, these are an energy source for the horse but through different pathways. The time required for digestion in the large intestine is much greater than the small intestine, hence the term ‘slow release’ energy being applied to the fermentable carbohydrate group. Fibrous foods are typically processed over a 30-hour period in the hindgut.As the process of digestion and energy release is more gradual and does not result in a spike of glucose, the use of more fibrous carbohydrate sources is ideal when looking to provide energy in a more consistent format. Resting and early stages of work are best supported by a higher inclusion of fermentable carbohydrates. Equally once fit to avoid a situation in which the horse ‘boils over’, altering the main diet to marginally reduce starch and increase more fibrous fermentable carbohydrates can be of help.Cellulose and other fermentable carbohydrates are not analysed separately in the same manner as starch. Cellulose and lignocellulose are identified through a lab method known as acid detergent fibre (ADF). By looking at ADF and starch values, we can get a picture of the balance between the fast release and slow release sources that materials commonly fed to horses have. Cereals naturally provide more starch, whereas beet and alfalfa provide little starch but plenty of fermentable carbohydrates.Feeding IngredientStarch (%)ADF (%)Alfalfa231Sugar Beet1.525Wheatfeed2212Oats3816Barley505.5Through altering the amount of hard feed against additions such as chaff and soaked sugar beet pulp, it is quite easy to change the ratio of hydrolysable (fast release) and fermentable (slow release) carbohydrates in the total diet. Many yards will feed a lower protein diet on a day off, to alter intake against workload—or rather lack of workload. Carbohydrates, or more specifically the balance of carbohydrates, is equally worthy of consideration when adjusting the diet against any change in workload.Starch or Fermentable Carbohydrates?Whilst both are sources of energy and equally valuable to the horse, glucose from starch holds an advantage over VFAs from fermentable carbohydrates when it comes to availability during exercise. Glucose is more metabolically efficient. When working aerobically at slower speeds, glucose is metabolised at nearly twice the rate of VFAs to provide energy to the muscle for contraction. As speed and exertion increases and the horse works anaerobically, the body favours glucose as the energy source over VFAs. As such, starch is always needed in the diet of racehorses and too little starch can negatively impact on performance.The temptation may then exist to push starch intake upwards given its advantages. However, there are several drawbacks to too much starch in the diet aside from over excitability, including increased risk of disorders such as gastric ulceration, colic, tying-up and hindgut acidosis. VFAs derived from fermentable carbohydrates are available as an energy source when working at steadier speeds and contribute to daily energy requirements for basic bodily functions. They should not be discounted as less valuable. Getting the balance right between the two groups of carbohydrates can be a challenge, in which choice of hard feed plays a significant role.Carbohydrate profile of racing feedsHard feed forms by weight, the largest part of a racehorse’s daily intake. The balance of carbohydrate provided through the hard feed will determine the overall balance of the daily intake. Forage, whether hay or haylage, will be a consistent source of fermentable carbohydrate. Hard feeds in contrast are highly variable in the amount of starch vs. fermentable carbohydrate provided.The fibre content of hard feeds is expressed as ‘crude fibre’, and this value can be found on all feed tags. Crude fibre is a laboratory measure that includes most of the cellulose found in the feed but only some of the hemicellulose. It also includes some lignin, an indigestible type of fibre. As such, it is not a true measure of fibre in the feed, but as all horse feeds are required to use this same measure, it allows for comparisons between feeds. Starch can be directly measured and whilst not required to be stated on the feed tag, the majority of feed companies provide this information on their websites or through their nutritional helplines.Example FeedsRacing Feed 1Racing Feed 2Protein g/kg140140Starch g/kg280180Fibre g/kg70130The protein content of a feed has no correlation to the amount of starch or fibre present, and so it cannot be used as a predictor for determining whether the feed is best suited to hard and fast work or to steadier or more stamina-related work. The racing feed 1 example is a cereal-based feed and contains 28% starch (280g/kg), whereas racing feed 2 example contains cereals but in balance with more fibrous fermentable carbohydrate sources such as beet pulp and soya hulls, resulting in an 18% starch value (180g/kg). Fibre content is lower when starch is higher, as seen in racing feed 1, and increases as starch content lowers, as seen in racing feed 2.Both feeds are fortified with the appropriate vitamins and minerals so the choice becomes entirely related to the balance of carbohydrates. Combining feeds, such as the two examples above in different proportions, is often advised when wanting to slowly ‘step up’ or ‘ease off’ horses at various stages of training. Feeds once balanced for vitamins and minerals will not become unbalanced when combined together to give flexibility around the type of carbohydrate needed.SummaryThere are many sources of carbohydrate that form part of the daily diet of horses in training. The site of digestion determines the source of energy produced, either glucose from the small intestine or VFAs from the large intestine. Both sources are needed on a daily basis. The balance between these sources is important as it affects behaviour, digestive health and can reduce the risk of incidence of disorders such as tying-up, colic and hindgut acidosis. By using feeds with different ratios of starch and fibre, it is possible to alter the total daily balance of ‘fast release’ and ‘slow release’ carbohydrates against type of work and stage of fitness. Use of chaff and beet pulp in the feed program also brings flexibility when needing to increase intake of ‘slow release’ fermentable carbohydrates.Reading ListBulmer, L. S., Murray, J. A., Burns, N. M., Garber, A., Wemelsfelder, F., McEwan, N. R., & Hastie, P. M. (2019). High-starch diets alter equine faecal microbiota and increase behavioural reactivity. Scientific Reports, 9(1), 18621.Geor,J.G. Harris,A.P. Coenen,M. (2013) Equine Applied and Clinical Nutrition. London: Elsevier.Hoekstra,K.E. Newman,K. Kennedy,M.A.P. Pagan,J.D (1999). Effects of corn processing on glycemic responses in horses. In: Proc. 16th Equine Nutr. and Physiol. Soc. Symp. pp. 144-148.

By Catherine Rudenko

Carbohydrates are by far the largest component of any horse’s diet, typically two thirds by weight, yet we often focus more on other nutrients, such as protein—which in comparison forms only a small portion of the total diet at around 8-13%. Carbohydrates, specifically the balance between differing carbohydrate sources, influences three key areas relating to performance.

The choice of carbohydrate influences the type of energy available, providing varying proportions of ‘fast release’ or ‘slow release’ energy. The type of carbohydrate chosen also impacts behaviour, increasing or decreasing risk of excitability and certain stereotypical behaviours. Last, but by no means least, the choice of carbohydrate and the way in which it is fed impacts digestive health and the ability of the digestive system to convert food to ‘fuel’ for the body.

Getting the balance right between the different types of carbohydrates is important for getting the right results when having to adjust the intensity of training, when resting a horse and when working back up through the stages of fitness. 

What are carbohydrates? 

There are different ways of classifying or grouping carbohydrates, depending on whether you take things from the plant’s point of view or that of the digestive anatomy of the horse. Working with the horse in mind, carbohydrates are best classified by the section of the digestive system that they are processed in—either the small intestine or large intestine. The site of digestion determines the type of energy provided, often referred to as fast releasing for the small intestine and ‘slow releasing’ for the large intestine. The group of carbohydrates, known as hydrolysable carbohydrates, are the group behind the description of fast releasing, whilst the group known as fermentable carbohydrates are those forming the ‘slow releasing’ category. Within the fermentable group, there are three sub groups of rapid, medium and slow. 

Screenshot+2020-08-07+at+11.25.23.jpg

What are carbohydrates made of? 

There are many types of carbohydrates in the horse’s diet, ranging from simple sugars to more complex structures. They are defined by their degree of polymerisation, which refers to the way in which sugar units are joined together. How a carbohydrate is formed and the type of link present are important as they determine if digestion is possible in the small intestine or whether fermentation in the large intestine is required. This influences the type of energy available. 

For horses in training, the type of carbohydrate of particular interest is the polysaccharide group which includes starch, cellulose, hemicellulose and fructans amongst others. Starch is found in significant quantities in hard feeds, whilst cellulose and hemicellulose, amongst other fermentable carbohydrates are abundant in forages. Pasture is a source of fructans, which can change rapidly depending on growing conditions and daylight hours. 

Structure

Single sugars, also called simple sugars, comprise one unit only. They are categorised as monosaccharides—the most commonly known being glucose. For horses in training this is a highly valuable sugar as it is the main ‘fuel’ for muscles. Glucose forms the basis of many of the more complex structures of interest to horses in training.

When two sugars join together, they are known as a disaccharide—the best known being lactose which is found in mare’s milk. Oligosaccharides refer to more complex structures where more units are joined together—a common example being fructo-oligosaccharide (FOS) which many horses in training are specifically fed as a prebiotic to support digestive function. 

Type of Carbohydrate

Screenshot 2020-08-07 at 11.28.41.png

Polysaccharides, our group of particular interest, are significantly more complex chains that are branched and are not so easily digested as the simple sugars. The branched nature of polysaccharides, such as starch and cellulose, are the result of links between chains of sugars. The type of link present determines whether or not it will be possible for the horse to digest this form of carbohydrate in the small intestine or not.

Starch



Screenshot 2020-08-07 at 11.31.57.png

Starch is the primary carbohydrate of interest in our hard feeds. It is a hydrolysable carbohydrate, which can be digested in the small intestine, releasing glucose into the bloodstream. For horses in training this is the most important fast release energy source. Starch is found in all plants, with the highest quantities seen in cereals such as oats, barley and maize.

Composition of cereals commonly used in racing feeds

Starch is made up of two types of sugar chains: amylose and amylopectin, which are formed from glucose units. Amylose itself is easily digested, however amylopectin has a different type of bond connecting each branch, which the enzymes of the small intestine cannot break down. Feed processing, which changes the structure of starch and breaks apart the previously indigestible bonds, is therefore a key factor in ensuring that when starch is fed that the maximum amount of glucose is derived. 

Amylose and Amylopectin 

Feed processing comes in many forms, from simply crushing or rolling the grain to cooking techniques including micronizing, steam flaking, pelleting or extruding. The amount of processing required for what is deemed efficient digestion differs by grain type. Oats have a natural advantage within the cereal group as they can be fed whole, although processing can still improve digestion. Barley, wheat and maize cannot be fed whole or simply rolled. They require cooking to ensure that starch becomes available, and the impact of cooking processes is much greater for these grains. 

shutterstock_84453238 (2).jpg

The availability of starch is assessed through the amount of glucose released into the blood after feeding. The study below shows the effect of steam cooking maize (corn) compared to two processes that simply change the physical appearance, cracking or grinding. Steam-flaked maize is more available as shown by the greater glucose response. 

Starch is a fast release energy source, being digested in the small intestine, and the term can easily be misunderstood. It does not mean that the horse will suddenly run at top speed nor appear to be fuelled by ‘rocket fuel’. The word ‘fast’ relates to the relatively short time it takes for digestion to occur and glucose to be available. …

CLICK HERE to return to issue contents

ISSUE 57 (PRINT)

$6.95

ISSUE 57 (DIGITAL)

$3.99

WHY NOT SUBSCRIBE?

DON'T MISS OUT AND SUBSCRIBE TO RECEIVE THE NEXT FOUR ISSUES!

Four issue subscription - ONLY $24.95